Google Faces Another Massive Antitrust Blow: EU Upholds €2.4 Billion Fine Over Shopping Service Case

Google has once again found itself in the crosshairs of European regulators, as the EU General Court upheld a massive €2.42 billion fine levied against the tech giant in 2017. The European Commission had originally imposed the penalty for what it described as anti-competitive practices within Google Shopping, accusing the company of prioritizing its own services at the expense of competitors. The court’s decision reinforces a growing trend of scrutiny directed at tech giants in the region.

What Happened?

The case dates back to a 2017 ruling when EU regulators determined that Google had manipulated its search algorithms to unfairly advantage its own comparison shopping service. According to the European Commission, Google placed its shopping results more prominently on its pages while demoting competing services, giving the company a competitive edge and ultimately harming both rivals and consumers.

The court’s ruling underscored that Google’s practices led to a distortion in the marketplace. “Google’s behavior was not based on competition on the merits,” the ruling stated, making clear that the tech giant’s actions were not in line with the principles of fair market conduct. However, Google did manage to secure a minor victory, with the court rejecting certain elements of the EU’s case, including allegations of harm to general search engine competition​(Engadget)​(euronews).

Google’s Response

Google expressed disappointment with the ruling. In a statement, a Google spokesperson reiterated the company’s stance that its Shopping service was designed to benefit users and that the ruling overlooked the competition it faces, particularly from Amazon and other e-commerce giants. The spokesperson also indicated that Google may consider further appealing the decision, potentially bringing the case to the EU’s highest court, the European Court of Justice​(Engadget).

Long-Term Impacts on Google

This case is likely to have long-term ramifications for Google’s business practices in Europe. The fine, though hefty, is a drop in the bucket for Google, whose parent company, Alphabet, is valued at over $2 trillion. However, the ruling signals that the EU is committed to continuing its stringent regulatory oversight of the company, which may lead to more restrictive rules being imposed in the future.

Moreover, this ruling could serve as a precedent for other cases related to Google’s business operations in Europe. With antitrust cases piling up, it seems likely that Google will have to tread carefully to avoid further hefty penalties.

A History of Antitrust Suits

The Shopping service case is far from Google’s first brush with European regulators. Over the years, the tech giant has racked up billions in fines. In 2018, the EU slapped Google with a €4.34 billion fine over its Android operating system, accusing the company of stifling competition by pre-installing its search engine and Chrome browser on Android devices. Another notable case occurred in 2019 when Google was fined €1.49 billion for abusive advertising practices through its AdSense platform​(euronews).

In total, Google has paid over €8 billion in fines to the EU in recent years, making it one of the most targeted companies by European competition authorities. This sustained regulatory pressure highlights the EU’s aggressive stance against big tech and its commitment to maintaining competition in the digital market.

As Google navigates these legal battles, the question remains whether the company will make significant changes to its business model or continue contesting these rulings at the highest levels.

Tune in every Tuesday, 9:30AM – 10:00AM, to get the latest tech gist only on Cosoro Radio.